• See More Blogs »
    • Film Drunk
    • Warming Glow
    • With Leather
    • Smoking Section
    • Kissing Suzy Kolber
    • RealTalk NY
    • The Rap Up
    • BuzzCuts
    • Gamma Squad

Uproxx

Warming Glow
Warming Glow is a blog dedicated to the best and worst of television programming. Mostly the worst.


08.21.09 A STRAIGHT MAN DEFENDS ‘PROJECT RUNWAY’

project-runway6

My heterosexual credentials are solid.  I was in a fraternity in college.  I served in the Marines.  I went to war.  I have, on occasion, kissed girls.  I own a Rottweiler.  My favorite drink is whiskey. (Which is not to say that gay/bisexual men can’t do these things, but they’re typically associated with straight men.)  And yet, I love “Project Runway.”  What gives?

The notion that straight men can’t watch and enjoy “Runway” because it’s about fashion and therefore “gay” needs to be blown up, and I’d like to supply the C4 and detonation cord.  At my most meatheaded, I’m happy to point out that there’s plenty of eye candy to ogle on the show, from the models to host Heidi Klum to the two or three designers that I end up pulling for merely because they’re attractive and I’m extremely shallow.

But even the “hey, the chicks are hot” or “my wife makes me watch it” defenses do disservice to the show, as it’s one of the few reality competitions that fixates on the talent of the competitors and their creative process rather than the quips of judges or a live audience that brays at the slighest hint of criticism.  Tim Gunn accomplishes more with a frown and silence than Simon Cowell’s most searing critique.

Granted, there are times when us red-meat-eating straights are bound to roll our eyes at a fabulouthhhh designer (I still want to throw Season 4 winner Christian Siriano off a tall building) or the emotional peccadilloes of the contestants.  During last night’s Season 6 premiere, for example, Ari chose to meditate rather than sketch out a design, challenge-winner Christopher cried or came close to crying no fewer than three times, and ex-meth addict Johnny broke into tears and wanted to quit because he was faced with the enormous pressure of designing a dress — as if that were the sort of challenge he couldn’t have foreseen.  But these are the foibles that make the show entertaining; there are characters to hate, characters to laugh at, and characters you want to take out to dinner and make slow, passionate love to (hello, Irina).  That’s quality television, people.

So let’s shelve the macho pretense already.  “Project Runway” is the apex of reality television, and I’m not sorry for liking it.  It’s the closed-minded simpletons dismissing the show as “gay” who owe an apology.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, there are some Wham! records I need to go listen to.

29 Comments » TAGS: LIFETIME, PROJECT RUNWAY
Share
submit to reddit
Stumbleupon

« Previous Post
Next Post »

  • Links
  • Upcoming on Digg
  • Popular on Digg
KOBE JUST BEAT YOU IN H-O-R-S-E (With Leather)
say something nice (WWTDD)
EMMA WATSON LIKES HOCKEY (With Leather)
hahaha, fatty fell down! (WWTDD)
IT’S A MIGHTY MONDAY MORNING SUCK-OFF (With Leather)
miranda kerr deserves an apology (WWTDD)
SAINT ANDREW’S NET: THE PEACOCK (With Leather)
friday afternoon headlines (WWTDD)

There are 29 comments about:
A STRAIGHT MAN DEFENDS ‘PROJECT RUNWAY’

August 21st, 2009 at 11:26 am
Kid Presentable says:

You lose a bet or something?

August 21st, 2009 at 11:35 am
Jonson says:

“It’s the closed-minded simpletons dismissing the show as “gay” who owe an apology.”

I’m confused – who do we owe an apology to? The gays? Our televisions? Marines? Rottweilers? This post is confusing.

August 21st, 2009 at 11:35 am
Matlock says:

No dude, you’re totally right! I love cock too!

Wait…fuck.

August 21st, 2009 at 11:42 am
Tracer Bullet says:

Whatever, closet case.

August 21st, 2009 at 11:50 am
Danger Guerrero says:

I feel like Tim Gunn could shame the opposition and finalize the push for gay marriage in one 30 second commercial:

“So, you’re against gay marriage? (followed by 27 seconds of frowning and silence)”

August 21st, 2009 at 11:56 am
Xamot says:

Now, if you’ll excuse me, there are some Wham! records I need to go listen to.

hopefully, Careless Whisper

August 21st, 2009 at 12:03 pm
Grimey says:

I’d watch the show if all the contestants were there to make friends

August 21st, 2009 at 12:03 pm
Enrico Pallazzo says:

Uff, allow me a few words to shoot down your entire case:

The show is on fucking Lifetime. Faggot.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:07 pm
White Bread says:

I don’t know how being a Marine at war is a sign of you NOT being gay. The American military features the randiest bunch of queers I’ve ever met.

//Former Airman//

August 21st, 2009 at 12:12 pm
Johnny D says:

We need a GIF of Tim Gunn holding his chin in his hand, looking over his glasses with a withering look of disdain for a good 10 seconds, then pointing derisively at some hideous creation. There are so many instances this GIF would come in handy, but I have zero computer skills. Hopefully someone else can pull this off.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:14 pm
Eddie Baby says:

You are so gay! I would never catch more of than a glimpse of this show if I wasn’t married.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:16 pm
Matt says:

Enrico, I know you’re trying to be funny, but I think that crosses the line.

Bravo used to be the all-gay channel, and now it’s branched out into other programming. Same with Lifetime and women. Same with Cartoon Network. Same with Syfy.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:24 pm
Eddie Baby says:

Lifetime is a great channel if you like to see women used and abused. Yeah there’s that empowerment stuff in the end, but first they have to get the shit beaten out of them or raped or left at the roadside when the guy who is banging them learns they’re pregnant. Great channel.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:34 pm
Leapin_Lizards says:

As a general rule, if you’re in an argument over whether something’s gay or not, just think “what would my grandfather think?”

annnnnnnnnd I’m pretty sure he’d think you were a “poofter” for liking this show.

GRRR FOOTBALL!

August 21st, 2009 at 12:41 pm
William says:

Awesome. Ignore the dolts.

I love shows where people make shit. Project Runway and Top Chef kick ass because people with actual hard-earned skills are trying to make real things, often for real people.

It is also awesome to see arrogant, low-talent snots get humbled once in a while, but that’s just gravy. The meat of this show is makers making. As long as we’re trying to stave off economic collapse, it’d be nice to see more of that.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:42 pm
Zack says:

I was in a fraternity in college.

I think it’s funny that you used this as an example of your heterosexual credibility.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:55 pm
Matt says:

@Zack, I was merely using things that are stereotypes of masculinity. And I don’t think your assertion that frats aren’t heterosexual is off, as most men in fraternities are straight. There’s a great divide between what people view as homoerotic (fraternities, the military) and what is actually homosexual.

This here post be for intelligent discussion.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:56 pm
Matt says:

Rather, I DO think your assertion is off.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:57 pm
Duke of Madness says:

A quick word of advice, Uff: Don’t use “I was on the wrestling team” as heterosexual cred, OK?

/Just trying to help

August 21st, 2009 at 12:57 pm
Tim Was Tim says:

Lifetime is a great channel if you like to see women used and abused
http://www.theonion.com/content/news/empowered_man_murders_controlling

Uff, based on your link, Irina kinda looks like a man, baby.

August 21st, 2009 at 12:58 pm
Russ the Bus says:

im with you. i really like the show. but its very gay.

August 21st, 2009 at 1:11 pm
Kid Presentable says:

You can be straight in a fraternity, so long as your dad owns a dealership.

August 21st, 2009 at 1:47 pm
Guinny_Ire says:

Ufford’s Quote:
“I was in a fraternity in college. I served in the Marines. I went to war. I have, on occasion, kissed girls. I own a Rottweiler. My favorite drink is whiskey.”

Esera Tuaolo Quote:
My family lived in a hut with a dirt floor. I’d gone from that poverty to the fortunes of the NFL. Football gave me a college scholarship, the chance to buy a house for my mother, the opportunity to travel, and much more. My NFL career lasted nine years with five teams — the Green Bay Packers, Minnesota Vikings, Jacksonville Jaguars, Atlanta Falcons, and Carolina Panthers. I’ll go down in history as the first player to sing the national anthem and then start an NFL game, the first rookie nose guard to start all sixteen games, and the last guy to “tackle” John Elway in his storied Hall of Fame career.

The dream to succeed in the NFL and achieve all that football had to offer was at times a nightmare.

This is the story of how I dared to dream, not only of surviving professional football, but of living openly for who I am, a gay man.

Take the trench Ufford. Grab the nob and open up that closet door. You’re so close.

August 21st, 2009 at 1:55 pm
Strange Botwin says:

http://bit.ly/jiDf9 You’re Gay!

August 21st, 2009 at 2:07 pm
Tracer Bullet says:

Gay? Straight? Does it matter? We’re all good liberals here. I love my wife and child, you love the feeling of a burly man slipping his tube steak past your prostate. It’s just another part of the human experience.

August 21st, 2009 at 4:36 pm
KitKatty says:

Matt, I fully support your heterosexual interest in Project Runway. My husband watches it with me for the sole reason of making fun of everyone and everything on it. Speaking of that, I can’t believe you didn’t mention Ari’s spectacularly fashionable unitard or whatever that was she was meditating in.
And no mention of the see thru nightgown/dress? Now I’m questioning your masculinity.

August 21st, 2009 at 5:33 pm
Vodka says:

I’m with ya, Uff.

I watch that show with my girlfriend every fucking week. She’s a fashion designer, so it’s nice to have someone in the know when people design things that I could swear are a practical joke. Tim Gunn is awesome. Straightforward with his critiques, but doesn’t cut people down like an asshole. Heidi Klum is a goddess. Still. And along the lines of what William said, this show has people with actual talent, striving to make it in a cutthroat industry. Not Megan Wants An Amateur Dentist and Finger Remover.

Are we really resorting to homophobia on the internet now? Where nobody even knows who you really are if you don’t want them to?

Bring it.

August 21st, 2009 at 6:21 pm
Zack says:

And I don’t think your assertion that frats aren’t heterosexual is off, as most men in fraternities are straight.

The sheer number of negatives (don’t, aren’t, off) in this sentence are too confusing, so I’ll just point out that I was just trying to push your buttons and leave it at that. Personally, I quite enjoy Project Runway. Plus, Christopher is actually the cousin of one of my college roommates, so this season I’ve got someone specific to root for.

August 22nd, 2009 at 9:26 am
swing4 says:

Good Lord, people, it’s the 21st century. Haven’t we moved past inaccurate, ignorance-based stereotypes?

I was in a fraternity in college. I served in the Marines. I went to war. I have, on occasion, kissed girls. I own a Rottweiler.

You’re obviously not gay. You just have a small penis.

Comment on this post:

RELATED POSTS

[image]
PROJECT RUNWAY
WHAT’S ON 2NITE: ‘PROJECT RUNWAY’ FINALE
Project Runway (Lifetime) — It sucks that this season was on Lifetime and outdated and irrelevant, because it’s nice to [...]

[image]
PROJECT RUNWAY
WHAT’S ON TONIGHT: MMMM, RACHEL BILSON
Project Runway (Lifetime) — Rachel Bilson is the guest judge. I will adore her unapologetically forever and ever for being [...]

[image]
PROJECT RUNWAY
WHAT’S ON TONIGHT: PROJECT RUNWAY, FINALLY
Dammit, Gunn!  Stop trying to clothe Heidi! Project Runway (Lifetime) — The long-awaited, long-ago-wrapped Season 6 finally begins.  With the move [...]

[image]
LIFETIME
‘PROJECT RUNWAY’ CAST FINALLY REVEALED
The finale of the newest season of “Project Runway” was taped in February, but the show has been held in [...]

TOP POSTS ON WARMING GLOW

1
NBC UNCANCELS 'TRAUMA'
By all accounts, "Trauma" was basically a medical drama as imagin...

2
CATS CHILLIN' TO THESE WEEKEND LINKS
SITE NEWS: I gotta bounce early today to catch a flight. These ot...

THIS ROXX ON GAMMA SQUAD

LASERS! CATS! CRACKHEADS! FRIDAY!
No, this isn't about the SNL sketches, it's about an actual produ...

SKATEBOARD DOG ROCKS MY SOCKS OFF
Normally, fake viral videos are sucky and hamfisted, and give me...

TIME LORDS LOVE THIS COMPUTER
The first episode of Doctor Who ("An Unearthly Child") aired on t...

THIS ROXX ON FILM DRUNK

SORRY, TWILIGHTERS, GOOGLE NEVER LIES
Thanks to the magic of the internet, we have this screen shot fro...

AMERICAN GLADIATOR MOVIE STILL GOING FORWARD
(How nice am I for using former gladiator Gina Carano for the banne...

NUBS THE WAR DOG GETTING A MOVIE. HEART... SO WARM...
While patrolling the Syrian border, Marine Major Brian Dennis fou...

SITE NAVIGATION

  • About

EMAIL TIPS

  • warmingglow-tips@uproxx.com

FOLLOW US

  • FAN US ON FACEBOOK
  • @WARMINGGLOW ON TWITTER
  • RSS FEED

Site Archives