There are a lot of bad things to say about NBC’s Olympic coverage: the tape delays are unforgivable, its reliance on sappy melodrama distracts from the competition, and Bob Costas’s self-satisfaction over not aging the last twenty years is horrifying in HD, among other things. But I will give them credit for this: the Olympics is still way more watchable than “American Idol.” And for once, most of America actually agreed with me:
By creating The Perfect Olympics Storm in primetime, mired-in-fourth-place NBC finally and spectacularly broke “American Idol’s six-year unbeaten streak. In the course of what NBC modestly called “the greatest single day in Winter Olympics history” (because the U.S. captured six medals) the network averaged 29.4 million primetime viewers.
When it went head-to-head with “Idol” between 9 and 10 p.m., NBC’s Games-cast averaged 30.1 million viewers. Fox’s “Idol,” meanwhile, clocked 18.4 million devoted fans who stuck with the singing competition just so they could be the first to learn the identities of the remaining 17 utterly unknown semifinalists. It’s the first time “Idol” has been defeated since May 17 of 2004.
The Olympic telecast included the gold-silver combination of Lindsey Vonn and Julia Mancuso in the women’s downhill (and the ensuing foxy medal ceremony), Shaun White’s dominating halfpipe performance (complete with live swearing), and Shani Davis’s repeat gold medal in the 1000-meter speed skating race. Davis sounds just like Tiger Woods when he talks, by the way. Must be something about being a black guy in a white sport.
But the point here shouldn’t be my casually racist remarks. The point is that “American Idol” sucks diseased goat dong, and it’s always a special day when it loses — even if it means a win for Dick Ebersol’s Retard Brigade.


Hey genius, the Shaun White stuff was live on the East Coast. (Thus the swearing that I thought was pretty tame for a coach, but still caused a minor uproar)While NBC does have input on the scheduling of events, they don’t have complete control.
Yeah, I was really mad; cleverness and subtlety kind of took a back seat to juvenile name calling. Plus I like saying dick.
Geez Irish, that’s a hell of a good rant. Especially with all the liberal use of the word, “Dick.”
I don’t know where you live Zack, but here on the West Coast (two hours from Vancouver actually), the coverage was FAR from bearable. We didn’t get to see Shaun White’s magical mystery trick until after 11 p.m. I got so mad, I sent an angry/filthy rant to Dick Ebersol. I know it won’t change anything, but gee it felt good.
definitely NSFW:
http://tinyurl.com/ykdlfvx
Why doesn’t American Idol get the same support on the comment board here as Lost does when it gets millions more visitors and is on 17 times a week?
Because American Idol fans, dumb as they may be, aren’t insane.
And yet, The NYT is trumpeting “American Idol Beats Olympics and Endures as Gold Standard.”
NBC still sucks. I’m home sick, and I could be watching Lindsey Vonn et al ski right now, but Ebersol doesn’t want me to.
Suck it American Idol. I’m especially happy about this since I love skiing and hot female athletes (Vonn and Mancuso- not that swedish monster who yard-saled on the last jump…. although that was spectacular).
Doesn’t change the fact that NBC is hemorraging money showing the Olympics. Jeff Zucker WIN!
Imagine how big the ratings would be if someone would kill that daywalking homo, Shaun White!
That red-headed chick was pretty hot.
The Olympics would have pushed the amount of viewers to 40 million last night if it had offered commentary on snowboarding by figuring skating guru Dick Button.
He probably would have used a timely analogy like, “those kids are gliding around on their plastic slabs like their the Jetsons.”
As an aside, I like watching Dick Button because it proves that male figure skaters were ALWAYS uber-gay throughout the decades.
I’ll give NBC credit, last night’s Olympic coverage was bearable. We’ve been DVR’ing it each night so we can skip through the commercials and all the other obnoxious filler, and last night was the first time so far I haven’t ended up with a sore thumb by the end.
That’s OK, Shani. You still would have won that gold without Stephen Colbert saving your team financially.