The majority of new shows are complete bullcrap. Of the dozens of shows that premiered on a network channel during the 2010-2011 season, only three have been any good: “Bob’s Burgers,” “Lone Star,” and “Raising Hope” (all Fox shows incidentally) — and only “Hawaii Five-0″ was a breakout success.
All we have between May (when shows are picked up) and September (when they air) is optimism that this year will be as good as, say, the 1999-2000 season, when “Freaks and Geeks,” “Angel,” “Malcolm in the Middle,” “The West Wing,” “Popular,” and “Shasta McNasty” all debuted. With that in mind, here are the ten new pilots that sound the most promising.
#10. “How to Be a Gentleman”
“Homer and Marge Simpson raise Bart, Lisa, and baby Maggie.” That’s how my DVR describes “The Simpsons”, the greatest show of all time. Point is, it’s tough to judge a show by its blurb, especially when it comes to sitcoms. So, when deciding what new shows to watch, you’re left with two options: what do critics think and whether it stars anyone you like. The Wrap says “How to Be a Gentleman” is about “an oddball friendship between a straitlaced columnist and his less cultured pal/trainer” (ugh), starring Dave Foley, Rhys Darby, and David Hornsby, a.k.a. Rickety Cricket (not ugh).
#9. “Locke and Key”
TV shows with puns in their titles should usually be avoided like…well, like “Miss Match,” that horrific NBC show starring Alicia Silverstone from 2003 (God, I miss Jeff Zucker), but “Locke and Key” has potential. It’s based on a graphic novel (a phrase you’ll read again later) and has family patriarchs getting murdered, uncles played by “Carnivàle” actors, secret keys, and, most importantly, a creative team that includes Alex Kurtzman, Roberto Orci, and One Hour Photo director Mark Romanek. [Kurtzman and Orci are the geek heroes who wrote "Alias," Star Trek, Cowboys & Aliens, and -- less sexily -- the last two Transformers movies. -Ed.]
#8. “Alcatraz”
“Undercovers” notwithstanding, J.J. Abrams has an excellent track record on television, including “Felicity,” “Lost,” “Alias,” and “Fringe.” Along with former “Lost”-er Jorge Garcia and Sam “Not from the Front, but From the Side” Neil, Abrams is hoping to duplicate his previous successes with “Alcatraz,” about a team of FBI agents looking into the disappearance of a group of prisoners from 30 years ago. If it’s anything like The Rock, it’s worth a season pass on your DVR.
[Ed. note: The show will also star Sarah Jones, AKA Polly Zobelle from Season 2 of "Sons of Anarchy."]





I know a few people who worked on the Chelsea Handler pilot and a few that worked on Wonder Woman and everybody has said good things about Chelsea’s sitcom and terrible things about Wonderwoman
I can’t wait for Ringer and Wonder Woman. I think House of Lies sounded good.
Wow, aside from a possibly funny show with the Dave Foley and one of the main writers(and the guy who plays Rickety Cricket on It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia)what looks remotely interesting? Plenty of lulz will be had when Rest drops, just because it’s almost exactly like a film that’s in theaters right as I type. It has that guy who played the douche/designated drunk driver from the Hangover and short lived brilliant “Kitchen Confidential.”
Steven King’s son’s nom de plume is Joe Hill. His book “Horns” is the shit.
Also, screw all these shows except Sorkin’s. I’m queer for West Wing.
this blog is pathetic
Is anyone else even a little bit excited for Wilfred on FX?
Out of all the pilots “Ringer” sounds the most exciting and promising. I can’t wait for Sarah M Gellar’s return to tv land!
@Zan
Wait…Stephen King really named his son Joe? Joe King?…you know, being a writer, he should have noticed that…
Another reason Locke & Key has potential – the creator/writer of the graphic novel is Stephen King’s eldest son Joe.
I’ve missed Kristen Bell, Milo Ventamiglia, Sarah Michelle Gellar and Aaron Sorkin’s writing on my tv. I hope at least one of House of Lies, Rest, Ringer and More as the Story Develops are worthwhile.
So how do I keep reading this article? An ad just keeps popping up.
Did you read the pilots for any of these or are you just wasting everyone’s time with a completely uninformed opinion?
“The Simpsons” is the greatest show of all time? Seriously? It had many great, epic, wonderful, all-time list worthy episodes, but they not only killed the show a long, painfully long time ago but have paraded its mutulated, horribly unfunny corpse ever since. It has now had more crappy seasons than it had good. Thus it is automatically precluded from best show of all time consideration. If it ended back when it was awesome or at least average, then sure, but now with as bad as it has been for many seasons now, not a chance. I’d rather watch the entire run of Joey than most Simpsons episodes that have come out in the last several years.
Chelsea Handler must be a dynamo in the rack. I can see sleeping your way to a cable tv talk show that shows at midnight. But NBC ?
She must have MAD bedroom skillz.
Don’t hold NBC in such high esteem, this is the same network that gave Emeril Lagasse his own sitcom.
Chelsea Handler is a talentless cunt.
Lone Star lasted two episodes.
I have the desire to watch exactly ZERO of these shows.
i have to say the walking dead is FAR from the source material,and its not even that good its really boring.
Sweet Christ…please forgive the apostrophe in “WORLDS”.
So Sarah “Polly Zobelle” Jones…I was convinced that she was in an episode of “Undeclared” as a shallow girl with whom Lloyd tries to be monogamous to prove he can. Since Charlie Hunnam was Lloyd and is Jax Teller, I was all, “WORLD’S COLLIDE!” Turns out, the broad in “Undeclared” was Katherine Towne, Hunnam’s then wife. Oddly, in some pictures, Towne looks a whole lot like Jones, but in others nothing whatsoever.
True story. Pointless and boring. But totally true.
“The Wrap says “How to Be a Gentleman” is about “an oddball friendship between a straitlaced columnist and his less cultured pal/trainer” (ugh),” –
Isn’t that “The Odd Couple?”
@JC: it thought it was a smart show for smart people, big difference. It incorporated all of Sorkin’s most annoying quirks.
Aaron Sorkin could make my job seem interesting so I’m already looking forward to his HBO show… and I don’t have to worry about HBO fucking around with the time slot and going weeks without showing a new episode because America’s Fattest Dance Model Idol Voice Losers is showing in prime time for a month straight.
also I hope it has people walking and talking.
Studio 60 is great. It’s a show for smart people, which is why it didn’t last.
@Matt – Okay, in the fall. That’s autumn right? Kidding.
@GiantCrab They have Cops.
Smegga, the TV season starts in the fall. Think of it like the fiscal year.
Also, any show in its second season is no longer new.
@smegga now would be a good time to let it go.
I know this is going to sound all ultra-liberalish, but why can’t there be a good show with black/hispanic people in it? They do a whole bunch of crazy shit and yet we can’t find a decent show to out them in?
@Upstate – Yeah, but it started in the 2010 season which was explained up top. Lone Star premiered on 20th of September 2010. Justified on 16th March of 2010.
Unless seasons are different over there?
Sorkin could write about 18th century chess players and I’d season pass it sight unseen.
@Smegga, “Justified” is in its second season.
Damn you Buffy…. damn you
You have Lone Star and a cartoon as the best of the new shows but no Justified?
Your argument is invalid.
Is this real or one of those parody lists?
Big Raising Hope fan.
I also like Mr. Sunshine
/ducks chair
//gets hit by second chair
///still misses My Name is Earl
I’ve been told by the lady that Vodka is going into our DVR schedule. Yeah, because I won’t erase it.
Agreed, Bob’s Burgers is very funny and probably the only show worth watching on Fox’s Sunday night line-up.
If these are the most promising… yikes…
Bob’s Burgers is fantastic, by the way.
Most of these look like duds to me, but maybe something will surprise. I thought Bob’s Burgers was going to be a colossal flop, but I agree that it has been a very pleasant surprise. Only new show this year I make a point to watch.
Nothing on your menu appears appetizing sir. I demand to speak with your manager! (though I may be the only other person here who though lone star was good.)
I predict the Dave Foley/Rhys Darby/Rickety Cricket comedy is hilarious and is cancelled within two months.
“Murray? Present.”
I might have to give “How to Be a Gentleman” a chance because of Dave Foley, Murray from FotC (“present”) and Rickety Cricket.
Also, Chelsea Handler is the worst.
Also, this post just serves as a cruel reminder that my pilot, “Sticky Finger Esquire” (about a slick, fancy art thief whose cover is a bumbling defense attorney) wasn’t picked up. Thanks a lot, Josh.
Ugh.
Other than “House of Lies” (because of Cheadle and Bell)and the “Wonder Woman/Charlie’s Angels” block (because, well, tits!) I can’t see watching any of these.
PITT THE ELDER
Chelsea Handler could wear a flashing neon “AMIRITE LADIES” sign as a necklace and it would make her more subtle.