Shatner Is Miscast in ‘My Dad Says’
05.27.10CBS’s “$#*! My Dad Says” has been in the news a lot, from the twitter feed that serves as its inspiration, to the casting of William Shatner as the titular dad, to bleeping the swear word instead of using the word “Stuff,” to the outrage the Parents Television Council expressed over the bleep. It’ll continue to be a buzzworthy show until it debuts in the fall.
The video below offers a first look at “$#*!” — and yes, that’s how CBS is “spelling” it — and I know that the cool thing to do is praise Shatner because he’s awesome, but I can’t help but feel that he’s miscast here. The role of the dad needed to be one of the all-time cranks, like Bryan Cox or Rip Torn or Albert Finney or Walter Matthau or drunk Orson Welles (what’s that? Matthau and Welles are dead? Well then, they’re probably crankier than ever).
Shatner has a gleeful pompous charm that’s irrepressible. It made for wonderful scenery-chewing with James Spader in “Boston Legal,” but he sanitizes Justin Halpern’s cranky, profane father to the point of sitcom stereotype. Which is probably exactly what CBS wants.





